Super Rugby

NZ Commentator highlights home bias referee concerns


Super Rugby Quick Links : Home | News | Fixtures | Super Rugby Betting | Standings |

Sky New Zealand Rugby commentator Tony Johnson has questioned Sanzaar’s local referee appointments for this weekend’s Super Rugby qualifiers.

Earlier this week Super Rugby’s ruling body Sanzaar announced the match officials for the weekend’s matches and given all of the home teams a local referee.

Johnson questions why Sanzaar have neglected the obvious opportunity to utilize neutral referees at such a crucial time in the tournament and predicted that, “There will be tears at some point over the reffing”.

“I cannot see why Sanzar (has) seen fit to appoint an Aussie to referee a Kiwi-Aussie game in Aussie, a Kiwi to ref a Kiwi-Saffa game in NZ, and two Saffa refs to police two Saffa-Kiwi games in SA,” said Johnson in his column for SuperSport.

“Have they run out of money? Do they like controversy?” questioned Johnson.

Brumbies v Higlanders – Angus Gardner (Australia)
Hurricanes v Sharks – Glen Jackson (New Zealand)
Lions v Crusaders – Craig Joubert (South Africa)
Stormers v Chiefs – Jaco Peyper (South Africa)

Johnson is not questioning the honesty or professionalism of the match officials in any way but as 135 Super Rugby matches have been played up to this point it would seem an easy decision to appoint neutral referees which would prevent the slightest suspicion or comment on “home town referee” decisions.

What makes the appointments all the more surprising is that just two weeks ago Sanzaar appointed Durban’s Stuart Berry for the Sharks v Cheetahs clash in Durban.

After that match in Round 16 the Cheetahs laid an official complaint against Berry for numerous decisions he made in the match. Berry has been absent on the match officials list since then but without knowing the reasons for the appointments it does appear that Sanzaar have invited further controversy.

Recommended for you


  1. Johann Fenske

    21st July 2016 at 10:37 am

    Its nothing new is it? We will see some very controversial decisions again because of Sanzaars shortcomings. And it will cost teams the game and a place!

  2. Godfrey

    22nd July 2016 at 1:29 am

    Tony Johnson is as usual spot on. The refs are not going to openly cheat but SANZAAR make it harder for them to be neutral or for disappointed supporters not to make accusations. I was spitting venom last week when Glen Jackson seemed to show his Hamilton colours while reffing the Chiefs v Highlanders game. The Chiefs are not an easy to like side (unless you live in Hamilton) but Jackson’s over-ruling of 2 consecutive Highlanders tries was hard to accept.

  3. Rob Beechey

    22nd July 2016 at 8:43 pm

    This is appalling. Historically, South African refs can’t be trusted. Two many have been influenced by a fanatically packed stadium. The bar should be closed during SANZA meetings.

  4. John mitchley

    6th August 2016 at 8:35 am

    Tony been quiet about the ref for the final?

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.