World Rugby Boss ‘completely embarrassed’ by Sanzaar’s lack of consistency


Super Rugby Quick Links : Home | News | Fixtures | Super Rugby Betting | Standings |

World Rugby Vice Chairman Agustin Pichot says that he has been left ‘completely embarrassed’ by Sanzaar’s failure to cite Owen Franks in the All Blacks victory over the Wallabies.

Pichot has called for a complete overhaul of the judicial system after Franks came into contact with Kane Douglas’ eye in the second Bledisloe Cup Rugby Championship match.

All Black prop Franks was not cited or warned for the alleged eye-gouge while trying to clear Douglas out of a maul and Pichot is not impressed that Sanzaar took no action after the incident.

The Sanzaar citing commissioner determined that the Franks incident did not reach a red card threshold so it was left alone.

World Rugby say that they cannot challenge rulings on foul play as Sanzaar tournaments are outside their jurisdiction.

But Pichot is not impressed at all with Sanzaar’s response to the incident.

“The process is wrong,” he said. “It should have some guidelines from the game itself.”

“In world rugby, in Sanzaar and in Six Nations, we need to find consistency because at the end of the day fans want that. They want to understand what’s going on and at the moment nobody can. I’m not saying Franks should be punished or not. What I am saying is you need consistency.”

Pichot explained that on Wednesday last week he was called on the phone by Pumas lock Mariano Galarza who was slapped with a nine week suspension after being found guilty of eye-gouging All Blacks lock Brodie Retallick in the opening match of the Rugby World Cup.

“I am completely embarrassed.”

“I cannot explain to Galarza who was suspended for an offence on an All Black when he touched his face and the same case or worse last weekend doesn’t even get cited. It’s wrong,” Pichot told Stuff.

“How do I explain to Galarza when he phoned me that he was left out of the World Cup from the start to the finish and another player in the same situation one year later doesn’t even get cited.

“What do I tell him as an administrator of the game? I am completely embarrassed. He dreamed of playing in a World Cup and I can now not tell him that it was fair.

“What is fair? Not citing Franks, or giving a punishment to Galarza? Where do I draw a line?

“We are the ones that administrate the game and we need consistency. I’m not criticising the citing officer. I’m not criticising the player. I’m criticising the consistency.

“It’s wrong for the players because at the end of the day it’s a question of integrity and player welfare.

“The same with consistency of refereeing. We can get some calls wrong or right we are human beings and we always have to respect the referee, but we have to be consistent worldwide.

“A French referee (Romain Poite officiated the test in Wellington) that comes in to referee a Rugby Championship game cannot be so inconsistent.”

Pichot said changes must be made and suggested that a central base for referees and judicial matters to be guided was being discussed by World Rugby in Dublin and Sanzaar officials.

“We need to change the whole process. We need to centralise the referees and work together on the global management of the game. It needs to have independence but have some common sense and rugby sense in the people that run the judicial process – not only lawyers. ”

“We need to revolutionise everything. We have to at least try because at the end of the day players need consistency.”

Recommended for you


  1. Liu

    6th September 2016 at 3:48 am

    Most referees in world rugby are favoring the all blacks.

    • Ray

      6th September 2016 at 12:02 pm

      Rubbish Australia got away with heaps that game .the coach is just using it as a excuse .

  2. John O'Connor

    6th September 2016 at 9:27 am

    As the Australian concerned has said there was nothing to cite it seems completely stupid for the big chief to comment in such a way. It brings the whole thing down to the level of European rugby writers who continually denigrate our game. No crime, no punishment, simple.

    • Oskkar

      7th September 2016 at 6:46 pm

      Or.. two crimes, different punishment according to the criminal’s profile. It’s not European rugby “writers” the one who denigrates “your” game, but precisely these “double standards” regarding discipline issues

  3. Mad Tripp

    7th September 2016 at 10:44 am

    I desagree. Galarza is an adult and one touhg internatonal too. I don’t believe he need any anwser alltougt he must be very angry. All Blacks are not Pumas, Italy is not France, and so on…the weight of their history makes the differents for the global competition as well as for the global bussines.

    • Fer

      7th September 2016 at 4:53 pm

      “All Blacks are not Pumas, Italy is not France, and so on”… Ok. BUT laws are laws, despite the jersey’s color. I mean the same fault (on purpose or not) deserves the same punishment

    • Oskkar

      7th September 2016 at 6:36 pm

      Are you advocating double standards? Sorry, “history” or “prestige” doesn’t allows anyone to be above regulations and laws. Should be exactly the opposite. Historical and prestigious teams should be showing the way and giving example of discipline and how to play respecting the rules. Shame on you

    • Oskkar

      7th September 2016 at 6:40 pm

      Or… maybe is it all about “bussines”? Awful take fella..

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.